Sample Polyaxis Profile
Take your own evaluationAll dimensions · 4 of 18
Territorial Authority
Your answers are broadly mixed on this dimension — neither pole clearly dominates.
95% of this axis's items answered (17 of 18) · high confidence
Principles (conceptual)
+30%
Practical choices (applied)
-4%
Register gap
34%
Question-level evidence
Strongest pulls toward Centralized
- Cities should be free to cap fees charged by delivery platforms, even if some firms leave those markets. In other words, platform fee caps limit the commission charged to restaurants, drivers, or customers.Strongly Disagree
- States or provinces should be free to set substantially different abortion laws even when the result is unequal access across the country. In other words, abortion policy should be decided regionally rather than forced into one national rule.Disagree
Strongest pulls toward Localized
- The national government should require public ownership of water utilities in every region even when local voters prefer private provision. In other words, a national mandate would remove local choice over whether the utility is publicly or privately owned.Strongly Disagree
- National standards are necessary when local variation would produce unequal basic rights or services. In other words, the national government should set minimum rules when local differences would deny people basic rights or services.Disagree
- Regions should be free to experiment with substantially different policies. In other words, different regions should be allowed to try different policies and learn from the results.Agree
17 answered (11 neutral) · 1 not sure
Show conceptual answers (5)
National standards are necessary when local variation would produce unequal basic rights or services. In other words, the national government should set minimum rules when local differences would deny people basic rights or services.
Large-scale problems are usually handled best by a central government with broad coordinating authority. In other words, problems affecting many regions often need one central authority to coordinate the response.
Decisions should normally be made by the smallest jurisdiction capable of handling them. In other words, decisions should stay local unless a larger government is needed to solve the problem.
Regions should be free to experiment with substantially different policies. In other words, different regions should be allowed to try different policies and learn from the results.
Subnational governments should retain meaningful authority that the national government cannot easily revoke. In other words, states, provinces, or regions should have protected powers that the national government cannot easily take away.
Show practical answers (12)
National election-administration standards should govern ballot access, counting procedures, and post-election audits in every region. In other words, one national set of minimum rules would govern who gets on the ballot, how votes are counted, and how results are checked.
The national government should be able to approve interstate transmission lines after a uniform review, even when individual localities object. In other words, transmission lines move electricity over long distances and often cross many local jurisdictions.
A national disaster agency should be able to direct resources and personnel across state or provincial boundaries during a major catastrophe. In other words, central command allows one authority to allocate scarce personnel and equipment across jurisdictions.
A national minimum school-funding floor should prevent poor regions from offering substantially fewer basic educational resources. In other words, a funding floor sets a national minimum while allowing regions to spend more.
States or provinces should set most school curricula rather than follow a single national curriculum. In other words, curriculum authority determines required subjects, standards, and instructional frameworks.
Municipalities should control zoning and housing density unless their decisions create clearly demonstrated harms outside their borders. In other words, zoning regulates land uses, building types, and development density.
Indigenous or tribal governments should have primary authority over land use and natural resources within their recognized territories. In other words, legally recognized Indigenous or tribal governments would make the first decision about land and resources in their own territories.
Regions should be free to adopt different tax and social-policy models so voters can compare real alternatives. In other words, policy experimentation allows jurisdictions to test different approaches under comparable national rules.
Cities should be free to cap fees charged by delivery platforms, even if some firms leave those markets. In other words, platform fee caps limit the commission charged to restaurants, drivers, or customers.
The national government should require public ownership of water utilities in every region even when local voters prefer private provision. In other words, a national mandate would remove local choice over whether the utility is publicly or privately owned.
A single national law should determine the basic legality of abortion rather than allowing states or provinces to adopt substantially different rules. In other words, the country should have one minimum legal framework for abortion instead of a patchwork based on where a person lives.
States or provinces should be free to set substantially different abortion laws even when the result is unequal access across the country. In other words, abortion policy should be decided regionally rather than forced into one national rule.
Show not-sure answers (1)
When Territorial Authority collides with other values:
Centralized won against Sovereigntist (Sovereignty Scope) but lost to Integrationist (Sovereignty Scope) — the framing decided.
Market-Directed survived both framings (vs Localized (Territorial Authority) and Centralized (Territorial Authority)).
Direct Democracy lost under both framings (vs Centralized (Territorial Authority) and Localized (Territorial Authority)).